How do you know what you know?

A collection of thoughts by Sarah Daud

What did Sydney Harris mean when he said that “The real danger is not that computers will begin to think like men, but that men will begin to think like computers”?

It is well known that humans have emotions. Some emotions don’t even have a word to describe it, but they are still experienced. Sydney Harris probably saw it to be dangerous that humans would start becoming computers because the emotions that humans experience are exactly what make them “human”. The word “human” has become an adjective, and it is characterized by the different emotions that we have. Computers, on the contrary, are characterized by their mechanical processes, and their inputs and outputs. The danger in “becoming” computers would be that we would not be able to differentiate between right and wrong, or happy and sad, or patient and angry. We would be emotionless. We would not be the social animals that psychology categorizes us as. We would just do what we were told, follow the input and produce an output. Emotions play a large role in the natural personality of humans, and becoming a computer would lose that. Often today, teenagers are seen glued to their computer screens or their iPhones. This is an ideal example of humans becoming computers. If one was to attempt conversation with these technology-obsessed teenagers, they would barely respond due to their undivided attention to their devices. And it is becoming popular to incessantly reference a “meme” from the internet. In that case, humans are becoming like computers. A computer is only as capable and helpful as the person operating it. Humans can act as their own individual, and have no one controlling their emotions. Therefore, Sydney Harris meant that humans should not become computers because it would mean the end of feelings and emotions itself. 

Religion

The title of this post is quite a touchy, or sensitive, discussion topic in today’s society. My family and I were eating breakfast this morning, when somehow the topic of religion came up. My mother is especially religious out of the five members in my family. Both my brothers consider themselves atheist. So when the discussion of religion arose, there were some opposing views on the existence of a divine being and the Holy Books in religion. My brother argued that there is no physical proof that the Holy books were sent down by a divine being, and therefore it is difficult to believe in such a thing. My mother argued that we have been taught these concepts and ideas since we were born and therefore we must follow them. I think I would have to agree with my brother, as I would also need physical proof to believe something. Something I can see. I cannot discuss this topic any further or in any more detail as it might offend some readers. However, I am very interested in discussing religion and have a few important questions about it. 

If God really did exist, and He wished for us to be content and satisfied with our lives, why is there still so much destruction in the world? Wouldn’t the people who cause it be punished by “God”?

My brother also said that it is very important to question the “definitive” concepts, such as religion or culture. If the experts on these are able to answer most questions posed, then it is certain that these cultures and religions are valid. 

Does sense perception perform fundamentally distinct functions in the arts and the sciences? To what extent does the artist make an advantage out of the subjective nature of sense perception, while the scientist regards it as an obstacle to be overcome?

Sense perception is a tool we use to witness and analyze our surroundings. There are different ways we can use them, although essentially they are used in the same way. There is vision, hearing, touching, tasting, and smelling. In the Arts, vision is used in a particular way. The subject requires one to use imagination and see one’s surroundings from a different perspective altogether. The auditory sense can also be used as a base to convey a visual idea in the Arts. For example, if an artist hears a sound that indicates “happiness”, such as a bird chirping, they would convey happiness in their art. If they hear a sound that indicates “anger” or “sorrow”, they would generally convey those emotions in their art.. There is also debate over what “happiness” is to different people. A bird chirping may indicate “happiness” for one artist, but it may indicate another emotion to another artist. It can depend on experience. Vision is an essential sense that is used by artists, as they gather colors of the surroundings. In the science, senses are used merely to collect information and to quantitatively/qualitatively analyze surroundings. A scientist does not have a different perspective on a bird chirping, or the color of the sky. They simply use their senses to form evidence and argument. Therefore, senses are used for completely different purposes in the Arts and the Sciences.

 The crucial part of the body, to a scientist and an artist, is the brain. Senses, technically, are used as bases or sources. The brain is the only way one can gather information as it processes what the senses collect. This is true for both arts and sciences. That is why artists may have different perspectives on things, as every person’s brain is structured differently. 

Sense Perception

In class today, we discussed sense perception. We had discussed it in the past before, but we looked more into it. Although I haven’t though of it before, but all our senses work together to gather information and to extract meaning. When there is context, which involves all senses being activated, there is more meaning. Empiricism is the concept that the only information we can have about reality is from our senses. 

On the topic of focus, one can only focus on one thing when observing one’s surroundings. That leads to oblivion to other objects around us, which could be harmful. We must ask ourselves the question, “Are our senses dependable?”. After doing so, we watched a couple of videos and looked at a couple of pictures that changed our perspective. The video, called “Changing color card trick” showed us that focusing on one thing can also lead to confusion. In this video, colors of several objects were changed quickly and subtly. Only a few people in our class noticed these changes. This is because of selective attentiveness. 

Our senses merely “feel” the surroundings; it is our brain that processes the information. Our ears feel vibrations of air, our brain processes it as sound. It is only light that reflects off of our eyes, our brain processes it as color. 

We also watched a very interesting video about a case of a murder that was closed with injustice. The unjust imprisonment of the “suspect” solely relied upon the eyewitnesses testimonial. A man named Scott Fraser showed us, in the video, that eye witnesses cannot be completely relied upon because our vision and brain can deceive us. I found it very interesting to see how our senses are not entirely reliable and a little more thinking is required when processing a situation or observation. Simply seeing is not believing. 

We are recommended to watch another video called “Questions No One Knows the Answers To”. I think I’ll watch it as the title itself sounds quite intriguing. 

Knowledge Issues

In class, we learned about what knowledge claims and knowledge issues are. Knowledge claims are definite statements in a subject. Knowledge issues are statements or questions that question the knowledge claim, with a WoK. For example, in the subject Math, a knowledge claim would be that 1+1=2. A knowledge issue would be “How is it possible to know if math is accurate to predict something?” or something along those lines. Our assignment was to pick knowledge claims from 3 subjects we studied last year, and create knowledge issues from them. I have already given one example of math. Another example would be English, where a knowledge claim would be “English is a universal language.” A knowledge issue would be “To what extent do the words we use represent our view of the world?”. Another example is in physics, “The force of gravity depends on the weight of the object”, and a knowledge issue would be “To what extent do humans experience gravity differently?” 

To be honest, I’m not very good at coming up with knowledge issues, although I do over-think certain things a lot. Hopefully I will improve this skill. 

What is TOK? And how do you know what you know?

I’ve missed blog entries for the first couple classes. In our first class, we discussed what TOK (Theory of Knowledge) is. TOK is a course that is mandatory for all students who take the full IB programme in high school. The only close-to-accurate way one can describe the content matter of TOK is with a question: “How do you know what you know?” That may confuse some, but it is a simple question that can be answered by different techniques and aspects. Areas of Knowledge, such as History, Human Sciences, Natural Sciences, Mathematics, Ethics, etc., are subjects we take into consideration when answering a debatable question. Ways of Knowing are personal aspects such as reason, sense perception, emotion, and language. Both these aspects are applied when answering a TOK question.

We learned how to categorize questions into definite, debatable, or no answer (as in, the debate could go on forever). I found that most questions are debatable because everyone has different views and there is always evidence or justification of some sort available to both sides of the opinion. For example, was Hitler a good leader? That is debatable because we would have to define what “good” and “leader” mean. Then, we also learnt about different types of justifications for a statement. For example, if I were to say that the sky is blue, the justification for that would be sense perception…because I can see it.

I really quite enjoy TOK as it opens my mind to other perspectives and make me think about things I haven’t really thought about before.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free